May 24, 2024
By Jennifer Webb, Director of Enrollment Management & Financial Aid, and Dawn Hopke, Associate Director of Enrollment Management

Depth vs. Acceleration: A Look at Deeper Learning in Flint Hill’s Lower School

In modern education, where the clamor for rapid progress often drowns out the subtleties of deeper learning, Flint Hill offers a refreshing departure from the status quo. Here, educational philosophy takes root not in the race for speed and acceleration but in foundational understanding. Drawing directly from neuroscience research, Flint Hill's approach emphasizes the importance of thorough comprehension over hurried advancement. It's a deliberate choice, one that prioritizes the long-term growth and holistic development of every student who walks through our doors.

Differentiation* in the classroom happens at every grade level to ensure students are met where they are and challenged to their fullest potential. The scope of our differentiation widens even more starting in 5th grade, when students begin to choose their course offerings, and later, with the many options for honors and AP courses in Middle and Upper School. However, Flint Hill's educational philosophy prioritizes deeper foundational and conceptual understanding over speed through grade skipping or acceleration (e.g. working a grade level ahead). Here's why:

1. Comprehensive Learning

Flint Hill recognizes that true mastery of any subject comes from a deep understanding of its fundamental concepts. Instead of rushing through material to cover more ground quickly, our faculty emphasizes taking the time to thoroughly grasp each concept before moving on. This ensures that students establish a solid foundation of knowledge that they can confidently build upon.

2. Holistic Development

Grade skipping or acceleration prioritizes academic advancement over other aspects of a student's development, such as social and emotional growth. By focusing on thorough understanding rather than speed, Flint Hill aims to support students in developing a well-rounded set of skills and abilities that will serve them beyond the classroom.

3. Long-Term Success

Rushing through material without a solid understanding can lead to gaps in knowledge that may become obstacles later on. By emphasizing deeper understanding, we set up students for long-term success by equipping them with the critical thinking skills and foundational knowledge they need to tackle complex problems and adapt to new situations throughout their lives.

4. Student-Centered Approach

Flint Hill recognizes that every student learns at their own pace and in their own way. By focusing on deeper understanding rather than speed, the school adopts a more individualized approach to education, allowing each student to progress at a pace that is appropriate for them and ensuring that every student is challenged.

In essence, Flint Hill's decision not to implement grade skipping or acceleration reflects our commitment to providing a high-quality education that prioritizes depth of understanding, holistic development, long-term success, and individualized learning for all students. This decision is grounded in these four neuroscience research findings:

1. Neuroplasticity and Deeper Learning

Neuroscience research has shown that the brain learns best when it can make meaningful connections between new information and existing knowledge. Rushing through material can limit the brain's ability to form these connections. By focusing on thorough understanding, our faculty capitalizes on the brain's neuroplasticity, enabling students to engage in deeper learning processes that facilitate long-term retention and application of knowledge.

2. Memory Consolidation

Studies have demonstrated that spaced repetition and deliberate practice are crucial for memory consolidation and retention. By emphasizing deeper understanding over speed, Flint Hill provides students with the opportunity for repeated exposure to key concepts, allowing for more effective memory consolidation. This approach not only enhances learning outcomes but also supports the development of robust neural networks associated with expertise in a particular subject area.

3. Metacognition and Problem-Solving Skills

Neuroscience research highlights the importance of metacognition — the ability to monitor and regulate one's own thinking processes — in effective learning. Deeper understanding requires students to engage in metacognitive practices such as self-reflection, monitoring comprehension, and identifying misconceptions. By prioritizing deeper conceptual understanding, we encourage the development of metacognitive skills that are essential for effective problem-solving and critical thinking.

4. Stress and Learning

High levels of stress can impair cognitive function and hinder learning. Neuroscience research suggests that when students feel rushed or pressured to keep pace with an accelerated curriculum, they may experience increased levels of stress that impede their ability to learn effectively. By fostering an environment where deeper understanding is valued over speed, our teachers help mitigate stress levels, creating a conducive atmosphere for optimal learning and cognitive performance.

By aligning our educational approach with insights from neuroscience research, Flint Hill ensures that students receive a rigorous education that maximizes learning outcomes, promotes cognitive development, and prepares them for lifelong success in an ever-changing world.

*Carol Ann Tomlinson, an author and teacher regarded as a pioneer in differentiated instruction, describes it as “a way of thinking about teaching which suggests that … we teach with an eye on the student.” She emphasizes four key pillars of differentiated instruction: Content, Process, Product, and Learning Environment.

Learn more about depth versus acceleration by taking a look at the following resources:


Fill out the form to receive updates from our team.


Director of the Upper School Don Paige shares six key pieces of advice he wishes parents knew before their students start high school.

A VAIS committee completed its 10-Year Accreditation Visit in April 2024. The committee reported its immediate findings in this short presentation to faculty and staff.

Students learn more deeply when engaging in productive struggle versus traditionally defined ‘rigor’

Head of School Patrick McHonett discusses our five core values and what they mean to our community.